
Report by Local Democracy Reporter – Jon Cooper
Derbyshire Liberal Democrats have described local authorities as ‘zombie councils’ stumbling through a stalled Local Government Reorganisation plan wasting millions of pounds of money in the struggle to merge the county’s ten councils into two unitary authorities.
County, district, borough and city councils in Derbyshire have been preparing since 2024 for LGR with Government plans to replace them with two larger unitary councils – a Derbyshire North Council and a Derbyshire South Council – between 2027 and 2028.
But after LGR was paused in September for some including Derbyshire amidst legal challenges the process stalled again in October for nine areas including Derbyshire which is awaiting a resolution as the County Councils Network raised concerns over the Government’s handling of LGR at its conference.
Derbyshire County Council opposition Liberal Democrat Leader, Cllr Tom Snowdon, said: “Huge amounts of time and money have already been wasted on preparing for abolishing councils, creating huge new ones and making staff redundant.
“In Derbyshire alone, the cost over three years is expected to be between £66 million to £81 million.
“All that, when councils are already starved of money. All that, to put Chesterfield’s affairs under the control of councillors from as far away as Ashbourne or Glossop.
“Local people will lose local democratic accountability. Local money will be asset stripped to meet the huge deficits haunting the county council.”
Chesterfield Borough Council opposition Liberal Democrat Paul Holmes accused the Labour-led authority in February of becoming a ‘zombie council’ during LGR, which was disputed by the authority which argued the current Local Government structure does not serve residents well but the council is still delivering high quality services.
Liberal Democrat campaigner Lucy Price said: “Councils are like zombies shuffling towards their end. They are not sure how long they have left. They cannot make long term plans for anything.”
Ms Price argued only Liberal Democrat councillors have voted against LGR on Derbyshire County Council and Chesterfield Borough Council.
Reform UK-controlled Derbyshire County Council backed CCN’s concerns over the LGR process warning that changes to the process risk undermining evidence-based proposals, wasting taxpayers’ money and creating councils that may not be sustainable for the future.
The County Council Leader, Cllr Alan Graves, told the CCN conference, on November 16, that the council supports Local Government reform where it can create better-run, more efficient councils, protect critical services and deliver better value for taxpayers.
But he added concerns have grown over the way the process is being conducted, particularly where the criteria councils were originally asked to work against appear to be receiving different weight.
CCN Chairperson, Lincolnshire County Council Leader Sean Matthews warned the LGR process has been repeatedly changed and he highlighted the enormous amounts of council time, money and resources already committed and he called for a robust, fair and transparent process.
Cllr Graves said the councils affected by LGR should have greater input because they are the experts responsible for the services any future unitary authorities will have to sustain.
He said: “Councils have invested significant officer time, expertise and public money in developing detailed proposals against the criteria set by Government.
“Changing the basis upon which those proposals are judged risks devaluing that work and raises legitimate questions about whether councils have been allowed to compete on a consistent basis.”
Cllr Graves reiterated his argument that for Derbyshire to be sustainable it should consider the case for a single unitary Derbyshire council instead of two north and south unitaries.
The Government has argued that LGR will provide more powers on planning and transport and create savings, greater efficiency, improved public services, and economic growth.
But critics are concerned about a reduced number of Derbyshire councillors, the loss of local control and decision-making, tax increases and whether the plans will create savings.
Amber Valley Borough Council has raised concerns and taken action over LGR plans to split its area into both the north and south Derbyshire unitary councils.
It stated that it is looking forward to further clarity on the next steps and the timetable, and it remains focussed on delivering services.
Devolution Minister Jim McMahon told the CCN conference he plans to bring forward a second batch of LGR decisions before Christmas with the remainder due in January or February, according to a Local Government Chronicle report.
He also stated, according to the LGC, that if councils cannot agree on what a perfect outcome should be, how can a Whitehall Minister be expected to do that on their behalf.
Local elections for Derbyshire and other unresolved areas will go ahead in May, 2027, on existing council boundaries, according to the Government, which stated that new unitary councils will be established by 2029 with elections to shadow unitaries in May 2028.
A North East Derbyshire District Council spokesperson said: “While Government considers the future arrangements for Local Government in Derbyshire, our priority remains delivering services for residents and communities in North East Derbyshire.”
